New Castle, IN 47362 909 S 21st Street

909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 1909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 2909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 3
19 more
909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 4909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 5909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 6909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 7909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 8909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 9909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 10909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 11909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 12909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 13909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 14909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 15909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 16909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 17909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 18909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 19909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 20909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 21909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 22909 S 21st Street New Castle, IN - Image 23
Presented By: Cheyenne Harp with F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate; Cell: 765-524-0911
  • MLS# 202625400
  • 06/26/2026
  • Get pre-approved
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 2
  • Baths • 1
  • SQFT • 1,288
  • Garage • 1

Home Details

Step inside this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home and appreciate the character that makes it truly special. A spacious foyer welcomes you into a home filled with beautiful original woodwork, built-ins, decorative trim, arched openings, and timeless architectural details. The generously sized living and dining rooms provide plenty of space for gathering and everyday living. The kitchen offers practical workspace and storage, while the unfinished basement provides additional storage and flexibility. Enjoy year-round comfort with central air, a gas furnace, and the peace of mind of a water heater thats approximately two years old. Outside, enjoy the covered front porch, fenced backyard, and detached 1-car garage. This well-maintained 1,288-square-foot home combines classic character, comfortable living, and a convenient New Castle location.
Presented By: Cheyenne Harp with F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate; Cell: 765-524-0911

Interior Features for 909 S 21st Street

Bedrooms

1st Bedroom LevelMain
1st Bedroom Width10
2nd Bedroom Length13
2nd Bedroom LevelMain
2nd Bedroom Width8
Above Grade Bedrooms2
Beds2
Below Grade Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Below Grade Baths0
Full Baths Below Grade0
Full Baths Main1
Full Baths Upper
Half Baths Below Grade
Half Baths Main
Half Baths Upper

Kitchen

Kitchen Length10
Kitchen Width13

Other Interior Features

Total Finished SqFt1288
Basement Y/NYes
Above Grade Finished SqFt1288
Above Grade Unfin. SqFt0
Below Grade Finished SqFt0
Below Grade Unfin. SqFt294
Living/Great Rm LevelMain
Main Level SqFt1288
BasementPartial Basement
Basement MaterialBlock, Poured Concrete
FireplaceLiving/Great Rm
Fireplace(s)1
FlooringHardwood Floors, Carpet, Laminate, Vinyl

Other Rooms

Dining Room Length13
Dining Room Width14
Living Room Length18
Living Room Width13
Total Rooms5

General for 909 S 21st Street

Age98
Agent First NameCheyenne
Agent Last NameHarp
AmenitiesCeiling Fan(s), Dryer Hook Up Electric, Foyer Entry, Natural Woodwork, Porch Covered, Range/Oven Hook Up Gas
Annual Taxes965
Architectural StyleOther
AreaHenry County
Assoc. Dues FrequencyNot Applicable
Associated Document Count2
Auction Y/NNo
Bathrooms1
CityNew Castle
ClassRESIDENTIAL
CoolingCentral Air
DOM29
Dining Room LevelMain
Elementary SchoolEastwood
FIPS Code18065
FireplacesYes
Full Baths1
GarageDetached
Half Baths
HeatingGas, Forced Air
High SchoolNew Castle
Kitchen LevelMain
Laundry Y/NMain
Legal DescriptionGRAND AVE ADD LOT 26 |
Lot Number26
Middle SchoolNew Castle
New ConstructionNo
PROPOSED FINANCINGConventional, FHA, USDA, VA
REONo
School DistrictNew Castle Community School Corp
SewerCity
StatusActive
StatusActive
Status Detail0
StyleOther
SubdivisionNone
Tax Year2026
Total Sq Ft1582
TownshipHenry
TypeSite-Built Home
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1928

Exterior for 909 S 21st Street

Approx. Lot Size Acres0.124
ExteriorAluminum
Garage Capacity1
Garage Length22
Garage SqFt352
Garage Width16
Garage Y/NYes
Lot DescriptionLevel
Lot Dimensions40x135
Lot Size Area5401
PoolNo
ROOF MATERIALShingle
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

High School New Castle High School
Middle School New Castle Middle School
Elementary School Eastwood Elementary School

Ryan Orr

Broker / Auctioneer
Price $149,900
MLS#202625400
List Date 06/26/2026
Property Type Single Family
Get pre-approved
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 909 S 21st Street