New Castle, IN 47362 423 S 11Th Street

423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 1423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 2423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 3
31 more
423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 4423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 5423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 6423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 7423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 8423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 9423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 10423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 11423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 12423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 13423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 14423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 15423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 16423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 17423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 18423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 19423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 20423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 21423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 22423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 23423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 24423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 25423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 26423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 27423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 28423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 29423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 30423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 31423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 32423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 33423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 34423 S 11Th Street New Castle, IN - Image 35
Presented By: Ashley Morris with RE/MAX First Integrity; Cell: 765-524-8599
  • MLS# 202616482
  • 05/04/2026
  • Get pre-approved
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Baths • 4
  • SQFT • 5,844

Home Details

Opportunity awaits with this well-located, former church property right in the center of New Castle. Situated in an established neighborhood, this distinctive, 5,844 sq ft building offers a versatile layout to fit a variety of needs. On the main level, the property features a large foyer entry with public restrooms. The foyer leads into the spacious sanctuary with vaulted ceilings and original stained glass windows. There is also a sound booth with a sound system included. Two additional rooms on the main level offer potential classroom, office, or storage options. On the lower level, you'll find a great room perfect for entertainment and gatherings conveniently located by the impressive, fully operational kitchen and two additional public restroom areas. The remaining 3 rooms would work great for office space, classrooms, or other needs. Outdoors, the property is a total of 1.22 acres with a large front yard, detached garage, covered drop off area, and private parking lot with +/- 38 spaces. The personal property in the facility is all included in the sale.
Presented By: Ashley Morris with RE/MAX First Integrity; Cell: 765-524-8599

Interior Features for 423 S 11Th Street

Other Interior Features

Basement Y/NYes
Burglar Alarm Y/NNo
Interior Height15'
Smoke/Fire Alarm Y/NYes
Water Heater Y/NYes
FIRE PROTECTIONCity
Equipment Y/NNo
Basement/FoundationFinished, Full Basement
FlooringCarpet
WallsDrywall

General for 423 S 11Th Street

# of Buildings1
Age126
Agent First NameAshley
Agent Last NameMorris
Annual Taxes
AreaHenry County
Associated Document Count1
Auction Y/NNo
Bathrooms4
Ceiling Height8'
CityNew Castle
ClassCOMMERCIAL
CoolingCentral Air
DOM15
FIPS Code18065
HeatingGas, Forced Air
Legal DescriptionNIXON HEIRS ADD LOTS 1 EX W 50', & LOTS 2 & 3
LocationCity
Lot Number0
New ConstructionNo
ParkingYes
ParkingLot, Off-Street, Paved
Present UseVacant-Best for Owner/Usr
REONo
RoofShingle
SewerCity
Special FeaturesBasement, Office Space, Public Restrooms
StatusActive
StatusActive
Status Detail0
Stories Count2
SubdivisionNone
Tax Year2026
TownshipHenry
TypeMixed Use
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1900

Exterior for 423 S 11Th Street

Approx. Lot Size Acres0.64
Construction Type 1brick
DrivewayAsphalt, Concrete, Gravel
ExteriorBrick
FenceNone
Ingress/EgressAsphalt
Lot Dimensions150X184.3
Lot Size Area27661
Parking Typelot
Road AccessCity
Security Light Y/NYes
Sprinkler System Y/NNo
Water FeaturesNone
Water Softener Y/NYes
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Ryan Orr

Associate
Price $274,900
MLS#202616482
List Date 05/04/2026
Property Type Commercial
Get pre-approved
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 423 S 11Th Street